WENN
You would think that when the day came to compare Nina Dobrev and Kristen Stewart to each other, it would be because their characters became vampires within the last year. (For those living under a rock, Nina on The Vampire Diaries and Kristen in Breaking Dawn — Part 1.) But actually, we thought this would be the perfect time to pit them against one another based on something totally different: Fifty Shades of Grey.
Is it completely kinda inappropriate? Yeah. TBH, though, it’s all anyone — including us — can talk about! And the reason why we’re having Nina and Kristen square off in this Celeb Battle is because both of their names have been dropped to play the title character, Anastasia Steele, in the movie version. But who would be the better choice, Nina or KStew?
You could go based on their acting skills and upcoming projects… Or you could just totally base your pick on which girl has the hotter boyfriend. That’s totally allowed.
WENN
And even though you have all that to think about, you should probably check out our most recent interviews with Nina Dobrev right here and Kristen Stewart right here! Tough competition, we know. Now, let’s get onto the fun part… the voting! Click your choice below, then tell us why you chose her in the comments!
Spread the Word
Nina and Ian. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Screw twilight
Ian is Christian Grey! Haven’t seen the perfect actress for Ana yet. Certainly not Emma Watson! Nina would be good but it’s not likely she could be paired with Ian since they are starring in a tv series. So keep lookin’! The person that plays Ana does need to be somewhat innocent but she also needs to be the unique individual that would attract a Christian Grey.
Nina Deffinetly! Kristen is no competition for her, she can’t even act!
Go Nina! She’s perfect for the role!!!
There are a lot of fans of twilight because they love Robert, they don’t like Kristen.
This sexy story is about those two that are very good actors that is why you like them
in the twilight, they will be prefect for 50 shads of gray,.they are in love they live together there is some freak in everybody I, think they would be good in this movie, they
will bring class and beauty and real love you want amit it but they are the best young
actres just think of the money they are making you don’t make that kind of money for
nothing. this is my first time ever hearing about Nina, I go to movie often and have
been a movie freak for over fourtyyears I, have seen the best of the best i, know stars
when I, see one. Robert and Kristen are to hot and beautiful to be vampiers in every movie they make.
I definately do not picture Kristen as Anastasia! She is not the petite thing that is described as Anastasia! Don’t take this in extreme, she is thin yes, but not petite!
NINA, kristen is so boring, NO Ian!!! HAYDEN CHRISTENTEN is my Christian Grey
I don’t think it should be Kristen Stewart.This movie deserves it’s own identity. And Nina is a bit too dark complected for the role and doesn’t have the big blue eyes as Ana does. There are a lot of wonderful young actresses out there that would be fine. Ian Somerhalder is my Christian Grey though, I can’t picture anyone else but him in this role. He’d be so perfect.
ILLL KRISTAN STEWART IS UGLY AND ROBERT PATTISON,, I GOT FOR THE OTHER TWO ..
NINA DIBREV AND IAN SOMERHALDER
Kristen!!!!! I can imagine only her.
The movie could be avoided from being turned into Porn. It could be made classier through suggestive scenes. For Christian I can only think of Henry Cavill.
I think that Kristen would be better suited. Let me explain. The story was, after all, based on a character she played. The person who wrote the book started it out as a Twilight fanfiction and then, of course, changed the names. You can obviously see while reading the book that the characters Christian and Ana are very similar to Edward and Bella (looks wise) The writer did change Christians eyes to grey (while Edwards was green as a human) and Ana’s to blue I believe, but the fact still remains that Ana’s looks etc are more similar to Kristen. And I know all of you people say “Oh, Kristen sucks as a actor blah blah fucking blah” Obviously the producers for the Twilight Saga, Speak, Catch that kid, Snow White and the Huntsmen, The Runaways, and on the Road does not believe the same as you. Keep in mind these people know a hell of a lot more than you. Not to say that Nina wouldn’t be good for this movie. I love her as an actor and especially on the Vampire Diaries…but I just think Kristen would be better for this specific movie. (Plus Nina has said she…really isn’t into this project and I’ve read that her boyfriend, Ian, was interested in it. I believe she said that if they both played in it, fans would only see them as Damon and Elena..not Christian and Ana.) Well..thats all I wanted to say. Thanks for reading!
there is nothing sexy about robert pattinson
True that!
NO IAN SOMERHALDER IS THE PERFECT CHRISTIAN GREY,Kristen would be an awesome young and Naive anastacia x
Kristen Stewart should not even be considered. Have u seen her in the MTV movie awards? I hope they don’t ruin this for me.
kiersten stewart is a terrible actress it would ruin the movie.
^Couldn’t agree more!!!
Me too ! She completly ruined twilight!
Nina beautiful
Nina! Nina! Nina! Nina! Nina! Nina! Nina!
Nina beautiful and sexy! She’s the best Anastasia!
Nina Dobrev!
I think Nina would be the perfect actress for the job
I chose Nina because she is more beautiful than Kristen!!!!
Only Nina!!!
I love Nina! She plays two completely different characters and is amazing at both! She’s such a talented actress!
I think I want to buy the book now just because I’ve heard so much about it! I don’t think it should be made into a film though. Sometimes, when films are made of really good books, the film isn’t very good in comparison and it kinda makes the book seem not as good.
I love both of theme, but Anastasia should play someone else.
how about neither one of them?
Fifty shades of grey should not be made into a movie. If it was honestly a movie, it would be a porno. And, it may just be me, but I would rather not have an actor I liked be labeled like the characters in this book.