Even with the quest to fill the judges’ seats on The X Factor now long over, there’s still another panel that needs celebrity occupants: American Idol. Since Jennifer Lopez has yet to agree to a new contract, and Randy Jackson and Steven Tyler‘s decisions are still up in the air, there may be an entirely fresh trio to look forward to on the 12th season of the reality-singing competition.
According to E!, ”No one has signed any contracts yet and producers are currently putting out feelers and setting up meetings to see who they can get. We won’t know if Randy and Steven are returning until they see who else is on board.”
But before you decide whether or not the upcoming season will be a drag, wait until you see who’s on the list of potentials for the FOX series… like Miley Cyrus! Though she was rumored to judge on The X Factor as well, the buzz for her to fill a slot on AI‘s been ramping up. Unfortunately, she hasn’t given anything away just yet besides a vague tweet that says she’s “got a lot on [her] mind” right now. Yes, bet she does.
Meanwhile, a more likely candidate’s name has also been tossed into the mix: Adam Lambert. Since he’s already an Idol alum, he would definitely be a popular choice. However, as recently as yesterday, Adam himself explains, “I’m just hearing about this today as well and so what a beautiful rumor. Listen, if — and I say ‘if’ with a capital I-F — if they were to approach me and if they were to say, ‘We want you to be a judge on the show,’ I would love that. I would jump at the chance.”
Other talked-about potentials include Katy Perry, Nicki Minaj, will.i.am, and Fergie. Who would you want to fill the panel? Think Miley would be a good choice? Or would you prefer the same three judges?
















All I have to say is if MILEY CRYUS is going to be a judge on AMERICAN IDOL that will be the first season ever that I will personally watch from beginning to end just for end, she’s just great
Miley!!!!!!!!!!
MILEY JUST MILEY STOP HATING HER
WE LOVE U TEEN QUEEN
MILEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
WE LOVE U GIRL WE NEED U IN American Idol WE LOVE U
WE NEED U IN American Idol LIKE WE NEED DEMI IN THE X FACTOR WE NEED U
SMILERS 4EVER
GO MILEY
MILEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY WE LOVE U
WE ADORE YA
U WILL BE THE BEST Judge on American Idol
GO TEEN QUEEN
GO MILEY CYRUS
o hell naw
I love Miley Cyrus she ia amazing and has alot of talent who I think should be judges are Miley Cyrus Katy perry and Steven Tyler or Randy Jackson
I would like if I like Katy Perry or Nicki Minaj were to host the show. I love them and they would make the show really fun to watch!!
YES! I AGREE 100% WITH U! Katy Perry or Nicki Minaji <3
I wish the members of One Direction would be the judges… sigh. Is One Direction getting a tv show on Nick??? I heard a rumor about it. That would be awsome!!!!!
One Direction are gonna be on the Australian X Factor im so excited!
I don’t watch that show. American Idol never appealed to me–and neither did its judges: Randy Jackson,Steven Tyler,and Jennifer Lopez. Although,if either Adam Lambert or Katy Perry were judges,I’d watch. If Miley Cyrus were a judge . . . I
wouldn’t watch. At. All. Simply my thoughts.
NO Please Not Miley!!! she’ll be a bad judge and she’s too young for this experience, it has to be someone who sang and been in the music industry for a long time i would say Katy Perry makes a perfect new judge
Please not will.i.am!! He was so good on the voice uk, so he should stay as a mentor. Plus, no one from the past few seasons of American Idol were any good. Just make it Miley Cyrus, Adam Lambert, and Fergie. None of them are very talented. They shouldn’t waste Katy Perry, Nicki Minaj, and Jennifer Lopez’s talent on a show that has barely a fourth of the viewers they’ve had in the past.
Hell no Adam and Miley should not! and i repeat should not be american idol judges i think either carrie underwood, jessica sanchez or kelly pickler should be judges because they know wat its like to be a contestent not that adam doesnt but mily does not know at all but we dnt want because she has a bad past and adam because we dnt need another guy we at least need 1 girl! not miley no one likes her some one but them run for american idol!!!!!!!!!!!!
And plus why is jennifer lopez leaving just for this guy really i think hes ur boy toy and u should not leave the shopw i luv u jLo dont leave becasue of ur Boy toy!!