ICYMI, someone is Rosewood is dying before the (confirmed!) fourth season during this year’s Halloween episode, “This is a Dark Ride.” ABC Family already narrowed down the choices to 13 Pretty Little Liars characters (which includes Aria, Spencer, Hanna and Emily, and they’d never kill them off. So basically, you have a choice of 9), but during the special screening of the show, Lucy Hale may’ve provided a little hint as to who it could be. Just look at where her eyes go as she says, “I’m looking at the person who’s dying.” We swear she’s looking off to the right (meaning Lucas, Noel, Paige, Spencer or Toby). C’mon, we can’t be the only ones who see her glance in that direction. Don’t believe us? Watch the interview above, then vote for the main character you think is getting the axe.